Rat-infested property is “suitable for use as a dwelling”
The First-tier Tribunal has found that a property in disrepair, inhabited by rodents, is still suitable for use as a dwelling for tax purposes. This sounds illogical - so what’s the full story?
In Mudan & Anor v HMRC the taxpayers (the Ms) purchased a £1.7m property in London that had been empty for five months after the previous tenants were evicted. During that time, the property had been broken into and vandalised, none of the utilities worked and mice and rat droppings covered the kitchen. The boiler had been ripped off the wall, the gas, electricity and water were not functioning safely and rainwater was leaking into the property. It took nine months of renovations before the Ms moved into the property.
Higher rates of stamp duty land tax (SDLT) are chargeable on residential properties, with the pertinent part of the definition being that the property is residential if it is “suitable for use as a dwelling”. Due to the state of the property, the Ms argued that it was not suitable to be occupied and so lower rates of SDLT should apply. HMRC, and ultimately, the tribunal disagreed. The judge confirmed that the bar for a property not to be suitable for use as a dwelling was set very high, and that a building which was recently used as a dwelling, has not in the interim been adapted for another use, and is capable of being so used again will count as a dwelling for SDLT purposes. An additional £100,000 SDLT was due on the purchase, and the appeal was dismissed.
Related Topics
-
The IHT exemption that HMRC hides
You have the task of obtaining probate for your mother’s estate which involves completing tricky inheritance (IHT) tax forms. One of these requires you to report lifetime gifts. How might the form’s wording cause you to miss out on an IHT exemption?
-
Gifts of shares to children: direct or via a trust?
You want to give away some shares in your company to help provide an income for your children. Is it better to make a direct gift to them or should you transfer the shares to a trust with your children as beneficiaries?
-
Are work-related benefits for disabled persons tax free?
A loyal employee has suffered a disability and needs special equipment to do her job. If she also uses the equipment in her personal life, will it count as a taxable benefit for her?